Here’s something you might never have expected me to agree with: Academics are very culturally conservative. The source is Mark Liberman at Language Log:

If you asked people to list the typical characteristics of academics, I doubt that they would often think of “conservative”. But academics are among the most culturally conservative groups around, in my experience.

What? Well, yes, considering that it is a certain sort of conservatism that he is referring to. Liberman quotes Phil Ford at Dial M for Musicology:

“Sometimes I think that academics have a kind of mental operating procedure designed to insulate them from having to consider anyone else’s ideas at all.”

Here is how Ford illustrated it:

trendy.jpg

Liberman filed this under humor, and I hope you’ll take it that way; but with perhaps a touch of truth to give it some kick.

Dare I suggest that something like this conservatism might be operating in a certain scientific controversy we often discuss here?

Trackback

No comment

Add your comment now

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
Formatting hints

Please read the Discussion Policies before posting.
I may not respond to all comments. If so, that does not mean I agree with what's been written. It may be instead that I'm involved in other topics or issues, or that I am doing something else–possibly even something fun!